The barefoot running movement made a provocative argument: the more sophisticated and cushioned the running shoe, the more it can mask and interfere with the body’s natural mechanics. The same thing happens in business. Contractors pile on services, processes, systems, and software believing more sophistication means a better business, when much of that complexity is a hidden tax that drags down margins and muddies the customer experience. Some of the most profitable home service businesses are radically simple. Stripping away the complexity often reveals a stronger business underneath.
That’s the whole idea. Let me open it up, because the complexity quietly piling up in your business is probably costing you more than you realize.
The Barefoot Argument
Let me set up the lesson with the running story, because it’s a great way to see the principle before we apply it to your business.
Some years back, a movement took off around barefoot and minimalist running, popularized by the book Born to Run. The core argument went like this: modern running shoes had gotten more and more sophisticated, more cushioning, more padding, more structure, more technology, all sold on the promise that more shoe meant better running. But the barefoot movement made the case that all that padding might actually be doing harm, that the thick cushioned shoe masks and interferes with the body’s natural running mechanics, weakening the foot and changing the stride in ways that could cause problems. Strip the shoe down, or take it off entirely, the argument went, and you let the body’s natural, powerful mechanics work the way they were built to.
Now, I’ll be straight with you: whether barefoot running is actually better for your body is genuinely debated, and I’m not here to give you running advice. The science goes back and forth. But the underlying principle the movement pointed at is what matters for us, and that principle is rock solid: more sophistication is not always better, and piling on complexity and padding can actually mask and impair the natural power of the thing underneath. Sometimes the fancy, cushioned, complicated version isn’t an upgrade at all, it’s a layer of stuff getting in the way of something that worked better when it was simple. Strip the excess away, and you can reveal a more natural, more powerful function that the complexity was hiding.
That principle applies to your business with uncomfortable precision, because contractors are champion complexity-adders. Let me show you how.
Contractors Are Complexity-Adders
Here’s what happens to almost every contractor business over time, and see if you recognize it in your own.
You start simple. Maybe one core service, a basic way of doing things, a lean operation. And then you grow, and as you grow, you add. You add another service, because a customer asked and it seemed like a good opportunity. Then another. You add a process to handle a problem that came up, then another process on top of that. You add a software tool, then another tool, then a third that overlaps with the first two. You add offerings, options, procedures, systems, layer after layer, year after year. And every single addition felt like progress at the time, felt like you were building a more sophisticated, more capable, better business.
But here’s what actually happened underneath all that adding. You piled padding on your business the same way the shoe companies piled padding on the shoe. Each layer felt like an upgrade, but collectively they added weight, cost, and friction, and started to mask and impair the natural power of your core business. The lean, focused operation you started with got buried under accumulated complexity, and the business got harder to run, more expensive to operate, and more confusing for everyone, not because any single addition was terrible, but because it all piled up.
Think of it like barnacles on a boat. No single barnacle sinks the ship, but over time they accumulate on the hull, adding drag, slowing the boat down, making it work harder to go the same speed. Your business accumulates complexity barnacles the same way, quietly, one at a time, until the whole thing is dragging and you can’t even remember when it got so heavy. And here’s the thing most contractors never consider: some of the most profitable, powerful home service businesses out there are radically simple. They do a few things exceptionally well with lean, clean operations, and they run circles, on margin and on ease, around the “sophisticated” competitor drowning in complexity. Simplicity, it turns out, is often the real competitive advantage. Let me show you what all that complexity is actually costing you.
Complexity Is a Hidden Tax
Here’s the reframe that changes how you see all the stuff you’ve accumulated: complexity is not a sign of a sophisticated business. It’s a hidden tax you’re paying every single day, whether you see it or not.
Most contractors think of added services, processes, and systems as assets, as evidence of a more capable business. But every one of them carries an ongoing cost, and a lot of that cost is invisible until you go looking for it. Each added service needs to be managed, marketed, trained on, and delivered, which takes time and attention. Each added process adds steps, bureaucracy, and places for things to go wrong. Each added software tool costs money, needs to be maintained, and adds one more thing to learn and manage. And crucially, a lot of that complexity doesn’t add anywhere near enough revenue to justify what it costs to carry. It just sits there, quietly taxing your business.
What does the complexity tax actually cost you? Administrative overhead, all the time and money spent managing the pile of systems and processes. Your own management attention and mental bandwidth, spread thin across too many things instead of focused on what matters, so you’re stretched and scattered. Confusion, for your team and your customers, because a complicated business is harder for everyone to understand and navigate. Slower operations and more friction, because every extra layer is one more thing to move through. And, underneath all of it, eroded margins, because all that overhead and inefficiency eats directly into your profit. It’s death by a thousand cuts, no single one of which seems significant, but which together bleed your business of money, speed, and clarity.
And the insidious part is that this tax is invisible on any report. You’ll never see a line item that says “complexity: profit lost.” You just feel a business that’s harder to run and less profitable than it should be, and you assume that’s just how it is at your size. It isn’t. A big chunk of that difficulty and margin erosion is the accumulated complexity tax, and unlike most taxes, this one you can actually cut. So let’s go find the complexity that isn’t paying for itself and strip it away.
Finding the Complexity That Isn’t Paying for Itself
Not all complexity is bad, to be clear. Some systems and services genuinely earn their keep, they add real value and real revenue that justifies their cost. The goal isn’t to strip your business down to nothing, it’s to find and remove the complexity that costs more than it’s worth, the padding that’s masking your power without adding enough value to justify itself. Here’s where to look.
Audit your offerings and services. Go through everything you offer and ask which services are actually profitable and worth the hassle, and which ones create a lot of overhead, headache, and management attention while contributing little profit. Most contractors have a few offerings that they keep around out of habit or a “we do everything” mentality, that are quietly money-losers or margin-drains once you account for the true cost of delivering them. This connects directly to the Hedgehog Concept I wrote about, the discipline to focus on what you can be the best at and make money on, and to say no to the scattered rest. Cutting the low-margin, high-hassle offerings is often the single biggest simplification win, because it removes a whole chain of complexity, the marketing, training, delivery, and management, all at once.
Audit your processes. Look at how work actually flows through your business and hunt for processes and steps that add bureaucracy without adding value. Over the years, procedures accumulate, extra approvals, extra steps, extra paperwork, that made sense once but now just slow things down and frustrate everyone. For each process, ask whether it genuinely adds value or just adds friction. Simplify the ones that are overcomplicated and eliminate the ones that don’t earn their place. Leaner processes mean faster operations and less overhead.
Audit your systems and software. Look at your whole stack of tools and software. A lot of contractors are paying for and juggling a pile of tools, half of which they barely use, or that overlap and do the same thing, or that add more complexity than they remove. Consolidate where you can, cut what you don’t really use, and simplify down to the tools that genuinely earn their keep. Every tool you cut is money saved and one less thing to manage and train on.
The test for everything: does it earn its keep? For every service, process, and system, ask the simple question: does this add enough value or revenue to justify its cost and complexity? If yes, keep it, it’s earning its place. If no, strip it. That one question, applied honestly across your business, will reveal a surprising amount of complexity that’s been quietly taxing you without paying its way. Cut it, and you lighten the whole ship.
Subtraction Is Progress
Here’s a mindset shift that most contractors need, because it runs against a deep instinct. We’re wired to believe that progress means adding, more services, more systems, more sophistication, more stuff. Adding feels like building, like growing, like getting better. And subtracting feels like retreat, like giving up, like going backward.
But the barefoot lesson flips that. Often, the real progress is in the subtraction. Taking the padding off the shoe wasn’t going backward, it was revealing a more natural, powerful function that the padding had been hiding. Stripping complexity out of your business isn’t retreat, it’s revealing the lean, powerful, profitable business that all the accumulated complexity had been burying. When you cut the low-margin service, simplify the bloated process, and consolidate the redundant tools, you’re not shrinking your business, you’re strengthening it, freeing up money, attention, and speed that the complexity was consuming. Subtraction, done right, is one of the most powerful forms of progress there is, and it’s one almost nobody uses because it doesn’t feel like progress.
So retrain your instinct. When you’re tempted to add something new, a new service, a new process, a new tool, pause and ask whether it will genuinely earn its keep or just add another barnacle. And regularly look for things to subtract, complexity to strip away, because guarding against complexity creep is an ongoing discipline, not a one-time cleanup. Complexity accumulates naturally and constantly, so keeping your business simple takes active, deliberate effort against the current. The contractors who build the leanest, most profitable, most powerful businesses are the ones who treat simplicity as a discipline they protect, resisting the constant urge to add and regularly stripping away what doesn’t earn its place. Make subtraction a tool you actually use.
The Double Win: Better Margins and Better Experience
Here’s the payoff that makes this a genuine no-brainer: stripping complexity improves your business in two ways at once. It’s not a trade-off where you give up something to get simpler. Simpler is better on both sides of the ledger.
First, better margins. All that complexity was costing you, in overhead, in wasted attention, in inefficiency, in the resources it consumed. Strip it away and those costs come off, which flows straight to your bottom line. A leaner, simpler business is a more profitable business, because you’re no longer paying the complexity tax. Less overhead, less waste, more margin.
Second, better customer experience, and this one surprises people. A simpler business is easier for customers to deal with. Fewer confusing options, clearer offerings, smoother processes, less friction, exactly the friction removal I wrote about with the Nordstrom approach. Complexity doesn’t just tax you internally, it often creates friction and confusion for customers too, and stripping it away makes you easier and more pleasant to do business with. So simplicity isn’t just cheaper to run, it’s a better experience for the people you serve.
That’s the double win. Simplifying your business makes it more profitable AND better for customers at the same time. You improve your margins and your customer experience with the same move. There aren’t many moves in business that improve both sides at once, and stripping away complexity that isn’t earning its keep is one of them. That’s why some of the most profitable home service businesses are also some of the simplest and easiest to deal with. They figured out that simplicity is a competitive advantage on both fronts, and they built their whole operation around it.
How to Roll This Out Starting Monday
Same rhythm as always. One area at a time.
Week one: audit your offerings. Go through everything you offer and honestly assess which services are genuinely profitable and worth the hassle, and which create a lot of overhead and headache for little profit. Identify the low-margin, high-hassle offerings that are candidates to cut, and start focusing on what you do best and most profitably.
Week two: audit your processes. Map how work flows through your business and find the processes and steps that add bureaucracy and friction without adding real value. Simplify the overcomplicated ones and eliminate the ones that don’t earn their place, so your operations get leaner and faster.
Week three: audit your systems and software. Review your whole stack of tools and cut what you barely use, consolidate what overlaps, and simplify down to the tools that genuinely earn their keep. Save the money and remove the management burden of a bloated tech stack.
Week four: make subtraction a discipline. Apply the “does it earn its keep” test across everything, commit to resisting the urge to add complexity that won’t pay for itself, and build a habit of regularly looking for things to strip away. Guard against complexity creep as an ongoing practice, not a one-time cleanup.
Four weeks to start stripping away the complexity that’s been quietly taxing your business, and a permanent discipline of keeping it lean. Do it, and you reveal the more profitable, more powerful, easier-to-run business that was buried under the padding all along.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the business lesson from barefoot running? That more sophistication isn’t always better, and piling on complexity and padding can mask and impair the natural power of the thing underneath. The barefoot movement argued that cushioned shoes interfere with the body’s natural mechanics. In business, contractors pile on services, processes, and systems believing more means better, when much of that complexity is actually a hidden tax dragging down the leaner, more powerful business underneath.
How does complexity hurt my contractor business? It acts as a hidden tax you pay daily. Every added service, process, and tool carries ongoing costs: administrative overhead, your scattered management attention, confusion for team and customers, slower operations, more friction, and eroded margins. Much of it doesn’t add enough revenue to justify its cost, so it quietly bleeds profit, speed, and clarity. It’s death by a thousand cuts, invisible on any report but very real.
How do I know which complexity to cut? Apply one test to every service, process, and system: does it add enough value or revenue to justify its cost and complexity? Audit your offerings for low-margin, high-hassle services, your processes for steps that add bureaucracy without value, and your software for tools you barely use or that overlap. Keep what genuinely earns its keep, and strip away what doesn’t. Not all complexity is bad, only the kind that costs more than it’s worth.
Isn’t cutting services and simplifying a step backward? No, it’s often the real progress. We’re wired to think adding is progress and subtracting is retreat, but stripping away complexity that isn’t earning its keep doesn’t shrink your business, it strengthens it, freeing up money, attention, and speed the complexity was consuming. Like taking the padding off the shoe to reveal natural power, subtraction reveals the lean, powerful, profitable business buried under accumulated complexity.
What are the benefits of simplifying my business? A double win: better margins and a better customer experience at once. Stripping complexity removes overhead, waste, and inefficiency, which flows straight to profit. It also makes your business easier for customers to deal with, fewer confusing options, clearer offerings, smoother processes, less friction. Simplicity is cheaper to run and better for customers simultaneously, which is why many of the most profitable home service businesses are also the simplest.
The Bottom Line
The barefoot running movement made a point that applies far beyond running: more padding, more sophistication, more complexity is not always better, and often it masks and impairs the natural power of what’s underneath. Contractors are champion complexity-adders, piling on services, processes, systems, and tools over the years, each addition feeling like progress while collectively they become barnacles dragging the whole business down.
That complexity is a hidden tax, quietly costing you in overhead, scattered attention, confusion, friction, and eroded margins, none of it visible on a report but all of it real. So go find the complexity that isn’t paying for itself. Audit your offerings, your processes, and your systems, and apply one honest test: does this earn its keep? Strip away what doesn’t, and treat subtraction as the real progress it is, guarding against complexity creep as an ongoing discipline.
Do it, and you get the double win, better margins and a better customer experience at the same time, revealing the lean, powerful, profitable business that was there all along, buried under the padding. Take off the shoe. Strip away the complexity. And let the natural power of a simple, focused business run free.
If you want help stripping away the complexity that’s quietly taxing your business and building lean, powerful operations, that’s the work we do with contractors every day. Book a free strategy session and let’s simplify your way to more profit.
Josh Kelly is Co-Founder of Clover Growth Partners, where he helps home service contractors build businesses that grow without depending on them being in every truck.